TAMRMS#: B05
4.1
title
Supervisor, Utilities Reliability Position
Notice given by: Councillor Hughes
label
BUDGET POSTPONED MOTION:
recommendation
That the Supervisor, Utilities Reliability position for $113,600 is unfunded and the utility rates are adjusted accordingly.
body
Administration’s Understanding of the Intent of the Motion:
That the Operating Business Case for the permanent Supervisor, Utilities Reliability position be unfunded in the amount of $113,600 and utility rates be adjusted accordingly.
SUMMARY
The Supervisor, Utilities Reliability position is intended to replace a temporary Utilities Supervisor role that was established to support the Cityworks Enterprise Maintenance Management and Asset Management (EMM-AM) implementation.
The position provides leadership for utility asset management, data governance, maintenance planning, performance measurement, and lifecycle optimization.
Unfunding the Business Case would result in a utility rate reduction of approximately $0.37 per month for a typical utility customer.
Administration anticipates that the operational and organizational impacts associated with eliminating the position would outweigh the short-term financial benefit.
ALIGNMENT TO COUNCIL DIRECTION OR MANDATORY STATUTORY PROVISION
N/A
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
The City of St. Albert is currently undertaking the implementation of Cityworks, the City's Enterprise Maintenance Management and Asset Management (EMM-AM) platform. This initiative represents a significant operational transformation that will establish how all assets, including Utilities are managed, maintained, monitored, and reported on for years to come.
To support this transition, a temporary Utilities Supervisor position was established. The position has provided leadership in areas such as asset inventory management, maintenance planning, work management processes, data quality, performance monitoring, and operational readiness for Cityworks implementation.
The proposed Supervisor, Utilities Reliability position is intended to replace the temporary role and provide long-term capacity for utility asset management and reliability functions. While Cityworks implementation was the initial driver for creating additional supervisory capacity, the need for ongoing asset management leadership extends beyond software implementation. Utilities infrastructure requires continuous monitoring, lifecycle planning, condition assessment, performance measurement, and maintenance optimization to ensure sustainable service delivery and effective investment decisions.
Accurate asset lifecycle information supports more informed capital planning, improved maintenance scheduling, enhanced data quality, and better prioritization of rehabilitation and replacement activities. These activities are intended to reduce reactive maintenance, emergency repairs, contractor reliance, and unplanned service disruptions while supporting the long-term sustainability of utility operations.
The next several years represent a critical period in establishing asset management practices and business processes associated with Cityworks. Decisions made during implementation regarding asset hierarchies, maintenance standards, data governance practices, and performance metrics will influence future operating and capital decisions across Utilities.
Administration notes that utility leadership resources have experienced pressures associated with increasing regulatory requirements, aging infrastructure, workforce management, operational complexity, and technology modernization efforts.
Should Council choose to unfund the permanent position, Administration would recommend maintaining the existing temporary Utilities Supervisor position during 2027 to support completion of the Cityworks implementation and transition activities. This would have long-term operational risks with no impact on utility rates for the 2027 budget year.
STAKEHOLDER COMMUNICATIONS OR ENGAGEMENT
The need for this position was identified through internal operational assessments associated with Cityworks implementation, utility asset management requirements, and leadership capacity within Utility Operations.
Internal engagement occurred with Public Operations, Utilities leadership, Asset Management, and Financial Services during development of the operating business case.
No external stakeholder engagement has been undertaken specific to this position.
IMPACTS OF RECOMMENDATION(S)
While short-term utility rate impacts are measurable, Administration anticipates that reduced capacity in asset management and reliability functions may increase long-term operating and capital costs through more reactive maintenance activities, emergency repairs, contractor reliance, and less optimized asset investment decisions.
Financial:
If the motion passes, $113,600 will be removed from budgeted expenses included withing the City’s Utility Rate Model and would result in a utility rate reduction of approximately $0.37 per month for a typical utility customer.
Compliance & Legal:
None at this time.
Program or Service:
The position supports utility reliability, maintenance planning, asset lifecycle management, and operational performance measurement. Unfunding the position would require these responsibilities to be absorbed by existing leadership resources or deferred.
This may reduce the organization's ability to fully leverage Cityworks capabilities and could limit opportunities to improve maintenance efficiency, resource deployment, asset performance, and long-term infrastructure planning.
Service levels are not anticipated to be immediately impacted; however, reduced asset management capacity may contribute to increased reactive work and reduced operational efficiency over time.
Organizational:
The Cityworks implementation has created a significant workload associated with system configuration, data governance, business process redesign, training, and organizational change management. The temporary Utilities Supervisor position was initially created to help address these demands.
Maintaining the position as a temporary role would provide short-term support while retaining staffing flexibility, but continued reliance on a temporary position creates risks related to employee turnover, retraining requirements, and loss of organizational knowledge.
Eliminating the position entirely would increase workload pressures on the remaining Utilities leadership team and reduce dedicated capacity for reliability, asset management, and performance improvement activities. Administration believes this could contribute to employee retention challenges and reduce organizational capacity to sustain the intended benefits of Cityworks implementation.
Risks
Operational Risk: Increased reliance on reactive maintenance approaches, emergency repairs, and ad hoc prioritization of work activities due to reduced asset management and reliability capacity.
Financial Risk: Potential increase in future operating and capital costs resulting from less optimized asset lifecycle planning, infrastructure investment decisions, and maintenance management practices.
People Risk: Increased workload demands on existing utility leadership staff, creating elevated risks related to employee burnout, turnover, succession planning, and knowledge retention.
Strategic Risk: Reduced ability to realize the full operational and financial benefits anticipated through the City's investment in the Cityworks EMM-AM platform.
Asset Management Risk: Reduced organizational capacity to establish and maintain high-quality asset data, performance metrics, and lifecycle management practices during a critical implementation period.
ALIGNMENT TO PRIORITIES IN COUNCIL’S STRATEGIC PLAN
Initiative aligned with Strategic Plan:
Mature Asset Management Program
ALIGNMENT TO LEVELS OF SERVICE DELIVERY
C.4.3 Waste Water Management
C.5.1 Stormwater Drainage Service
C.5.2 Water Supply and Distribution Management
G.9.1 Capital Project Management
Refined with AI support; reviewed and verified by a City employee.
body
Report Date: November 24, 2026
Author(s): Regan Lefebvre
Department: Public Operations, Utilities
Department Director: Tim Saunders
Managing Director: Dinu Alex
Chief Administrative Officer: William Fletcher