TAMRMS#: B05
5.1
title
ENGS-058 Pedestrian Curb Extensions (bulb-outs)
Notice given by: Councillor Clark
label
BUDGET POSTPONED MOTION:
recommendation
That funding for the portion to build pedestrian curb extensions (bulb-outs) be removed from ENGS-058 and all planned and incomplete pedestrian curb extensions be postponed until Council receives the expected 2027 assessment results, referenced in BIR -27-043, and approves continuation of this portion of the traffic calming program.
body
Administration’s Understanding of the Intent of the Motion:
Administration understands this motion, seeks to remove funding associated with any scope aligned to delivery of pedestrian curb extensions within the 2027 Traffic Calming program (charter ENGS-058); to which Administration has provided the cost estimate in Attachment 1 - Confidential PM-27-007 Pedestrian Curb Extensions (Bulb-Outs) and an updated charter showing the reduced value in Attachment 2 - Confidential PM-27-007 Pedestrian Curb Extensions (Bulb-Outs).
SUMMARY
• Council has an approved Traffic Calming Policy (C-TS-02) directing Administration to address resident traffic safety concerns at the neighbourhood level. Consistent with the policy, Administration is currently delivering a traffic calming program in the community of Riverside.
• The proposed 2027 Traffic Calming program expands upon the work completed in 2026 that involved resident engagement, plan development, and temporary measure implementation; and the next year’s program and associated funding empowers completion of assessments of temporary measures, final resident engagement, and detailed design and construction of permanent measures.
• Traffic Calming in of itself seeks to address various perceived and recordable traffic related concerns, such as pedestrian safety and vehicle speeds. Different Traffic Calming measures equate to different primary benefits and influence on safety.
• Administration intends to present information to Council in 2027 regarding the experience and lessons learned from delivering the Traffic Calming Program, as well as findings from the development of the Mobility Strategy. Administration will seek Council's input on the future direction of the Traffic Calming Policy and associated processes.
• The elimination of pedestrian curb extensions, which are a recognized and industry-accepted traffic calming measure, is not recommended by Administration.
ALIGNMENT TO COUNCIL DIRECTION OR MANDATORY STATUTORY PROVISION
On April 4, 2016, Council passed the following motions:
C-185-2016
1. That Council Policy C-TS-02 Neighbourhood Traffic Calming, provided as Attachment 1, to the April 4, 2016, Agenda Report entitled “Proposed Council Policy C-TS-02 Neighbourhood Traffic Calming” be approved.
2. That the Neighbourhood Traffic Calming Process and Guidelines, provided as Attachment 2, to the April 4, 2016, Agenda Report entitled “Proposed Council Policy C-TS-02 Neighbourhood Traffic Calming” be received as information.
3. That Administration move forward with a pilot of the Neighbourhood Traffic Calming Process within the community of Erin Ridge, starting in Q2 of 2016.
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
The Confidential attachments (Attachment 1 and Attachment 2 - Confidential PM-27-007 Pedestrian Curb Extensions (Bulb-Outs) provide conceptual cost estimates aligned with the scope associated with pedestrian curb extensions in the 2027 program, and also an updated project charter ENGS-058 Neighbourhood Traffic Calming.
This response is confidential in accordance with sections 26(1)(b), 29(1)(a), 29(1)(c), and 30(1)(c) of the Access to Information Act.
The two top traffic safety related concerns reported by residents requesting Traffic Calming are associated with vehicle speeds and pedestrian safety.
The Traffic Calming program addresses both key target areas (speed and pedestrian safety). Programming and plans are developed by applying different measures based upon resident engagement and information shared on types of issues and locations of concerns and operational (vehicle speeds) and safety (reported motor vehicle collision) information. In response to feedback and data, Traffic Calming measures are applied, each with different primary benefits and often supportive supplemental benefits.
Traffic Calming plans created and delivered in St Albert have largely involved addressing pedestrian safety through use of pedestrian curb extensions. Pedestrian curb extensions primarily empower greater visibility and driver awareness of pedestrian crossings and improve driver response to safely yielding to pedestrians. They also reduce the crossing distance and thus conflict time for pedestrians within the roadway. These benefits are not lost or reduced over time, as the signs and warning flashers are in greater position to be seen by the driver. A secondary influence of extensions is that the redesigned curb narrows the roadway from the driver’s perspective, and this can influence a driver’s travel speed to slow down. Over time, as drivers become more confident in traveling through these crossings, speeds may revert to a higher rate. This has been found in St Albert; where speed of vehicles may increase however, the primary benefit of improved pedestrian safety has been maintained.
Despite residents reporting speed as a critical issue, to date there has been a great deal of concern and negative resident opinion on the potential integration of vertical traffic calming measures. Vertical traffic calming measures, to which there is a grade change, include raised pedestrian crosswalks, raised intersections, speed humps or speed cushions. They primarily influence driver speeds. Additionally, raised pedestrian crosswalks can also have the added benefit of improved pedestrian accessibility for users with mobility challenges. The City has applied raised crosswalks permanently in locations in the community of Erin Ridge with improved results on speed reduction.
The planned temporary improvements in the community of Riverside (2027), which are inclusive of pedestrian curb extensions as well as speed cushions (vertical measures) have all been informed by resident feedback and requests. Discontinuing the delivery of measures that have been specifically requested and supported by residents may be contentious to this specific program delivery. Improved neighbourhood-level traffic safety is best served with applications of both styles of measures to achieve long-term safety improvements through reduction of speed and improved design of vulnerable road user and vehicle conflict points.
Administration is planning a presentation to Council on the topic of Traffic Calming, with information to share from the industry review completed during the development of the Mobility Strategy and from experiences and “lessons learned” from delivery of the Traffic Calming Program and Policy in the city. Current observations do not suggest removal of specific traffic measures from the program; however, the discussion involves the level of influence of resident feedback into the program delivery and decision making. Specifically, Administration is examining whether resident preferences should continue to significantly influence the selection of traffic calming measures even when those preferences may limit the overall effectiveness of the final solution.
Administration intends to have this discussion with Council in the new year and following Council's direction, Administration would update the associated policy and process as appropriate. This approach allows Council to remain focused on governance, policy direction, and desired outcomes, while Administration is responsible for the technical design and implementation of traffic calming solutions.
STAKEHOLDER COMMUNICATIONS OR ENGAGEMENT
The proposed Traffic Calming Program in 2027/2028 largely targets the continued work of delivering Traffic Calming improvements within the community of Riverside. This traffic calming is in response to citizen-lead demand for traffic calming. To date, there has been multiple actions from resident engagement to first confirm community support of applying Traffic Calming to the community, to identify issues and locations that were used to develop a concept plan for measures to be applied. Engagement has included:
1) 2023 / 2024 - Residents applied to the Transportation group for Traffic Calming
2) Fall 2024 - Community Support Survey to confirm support for Traffic Calming to be applied. 82% of respondents desired / supported Traffic Calming advancing.
3) Spring 2025 - Workshop conducted for issues and locations identification.
4) Fall 2025 - Survey of concept plan developed
5) Planned Engagement - Fall 2027: Community feedback on temporary measures.
IMPACTS OF RECOMMENDATION(S)
Financial:
If approved, funding for ENGS-058 Neighbourhood Traffic Calming would be reduced as per the Attachment 2 - Confidential PM-27-007 Pedestrian Curb Extensions which highlights the revised project charter (ENGS-058).
Administration believes that this reduction of scope could influence the potential of attaining future grant funding, as the planned safety improvements are not being largely delivered on. Administration would have to report this back to the Grant Authority.
Compliance & Legal:
None at this time.
Program or Service:
The Traffic Calming program itself is largely resident driven in terms of measures and supported applications. The removal of resident supported measures such as pedestrian curb extensions would need to be communicated to residents.
Organizational:
None at this time.
Risks
Eliminating pedestrian curb extensions would reduce the effectiveness of the Traffic Calming Program and create risk that the supported Traffic Calming Plan does not meet community expectations established through the planning and engagement process.
ALIGNMENT TO PRIORITIES IN COUNCIL’S STRATEGIC PLAN
Initiative aligned with Strategic Plan:
Not Applicable
ALIGNMENT TO LEVELS OF SERVICE DELIVERY
Not applicable.
body
Report Date: November 24, 2026
Author(s): Dean Schick, Transportation Manager
Department: Engineering
Department Director: Dawny George
Managing Director: Adryan Slaght
Chief Administrative Officer: William Fletcher