TAMRMS#: B05
6.3
title
Downtown Business Association Annual Grant
Notice given by: Councillor Korotash
label
BUDGET POSTPONED MOTION:
recommendation
That a grant in the amount of $22,000 per year for each year 2027-2030 be allocated to the Downtown Business Association to be funded through the Stabilization Fund.
body
Administration’s Understanding of the Intent of the Motion:
The motion seeks to establish a four-year annual grant arrangement, from 2027 to 2030, between the City and the Downtown Business Association (DBA), whereby the City would commit to contributing $22,000 annually. The total amount of $88,000 would be funded through the Stabilization Reserve.
SUMMARY
Established in late 2023, the St. Albert Downtown Business Association is an independent organization, representing approximately 115 downtown business owners, that governs and administers the Business Improvement Area (BIA) in downtown St. Albert.
The BIA is funded through an annual levy applied to businesses in the area, which is collected by the City of St. Albert on behalf of the BIA. The motion proposes to provide the DBA with supplemental operating funding through annual grant, in the amount of $22,000 per year, over the next four years.
St. Albert City Council’s strategic plan identifies supporting greater downtown vibrancy, under the Robust Economy & Responsible Growth priority.
ALIGNMENT TO COUNCIL DIRECTION OR MANDATORY STATUTORY PROVISION
The Municipal Government Act (MGA) Business Improvement Regulation provides that:
Section 11 (1) A board must submit a proposed budget for each calendar year to the council for the council’s approval.
(2) The proposed budget must be submitted at the time and in the form submitted by council.
(3) The proposed budget must be a balanced budget and include:
(a) the estimated amount of board’s revenue from every source, including the amount that the board will receive from the municipality in respect of the business improvement area tax, and
(b) The estimated amount of all operating and capital expenditures planning for the year.
21 (1) Each council that has passed a business improvement area tax bylaw must pass a business improvement area tax rate bylaw annually
On April 9, 2026, Council passed the 2026 Business Improvement Area Tax and Tax Rate Bylaw (Bylaw 15/2026).
On March 17, 2026, Council approved the 2026 Downtown Business Improvement Area Board & Budget (AR-26-116):
That the appointments of the Directors to the St. Albert Downtown Business Association’s Board, as set out in the attachment entitled “St. Albert DBA - 2026 Board of Directors,” be approved, each for a term of one year, from March 17, 2026, until March 16, 2027.
That the St. Albert Downtown Business Association’s proposed 2026 budget, as set out in the attachment entitled “St. Albert BIA - 2026 Proposed Budget,” be approved.
On November 27, 2023, Council approved Budget Postponed Motion (PM-24-06):
That the City matches the Downtown Business Improvement Area budget up to $50,000 at 100% for 2024, 75% in 2025, and 50% in 2026. Plus an additional $10,000 for the same three years to support the Snowflake Festival and the funds come from the tax base.
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
On September 19, 2023, Council unanimously approved Bylaw 21/2023, establishing the Downtown Business Improvement Area.
City Funding for the Downtown Business Association
The Downtown Business Association (the “DBA”), like all BIAs in Alberta, is funded through an annual Business Improvement Area (“BIA”) tax, which is assessed on businesses operating within the designated BIA boundaries. The City collects the tax on behalf of the DBA and transfers it to them in accordance with the Municipal Government Act and municipal bylaws.
In addition to the BIA tax, Council approved supplemental funding for the DBA from 2024 to 2026.
|
Downtown Business Association Funding |
|
Budget Year |
Business Improvement Area Tax |
Supplemental City Funding |
Total |
|
2024 |
$25,000 |
$25,000 |
$50,000 |
|
2025 |
$22,400 |
$16,800 |
$39,200 |
|
2026 |
$22,400 |
$11,200 |
$33,600 |
|
Total |
$69,800 |
$53,000 |
$122,800 |
|
Annual Average |
$23,267 |
$17,667 |
$40,934 |
From 2024 to 2026, the DBA received $69,800 through BIA tax and $53,000 through supplemental City funding.
New Supplemental Funding Request
At the November 3, 2026 City Council Meeting, DBA Board Executive, Alena Brown, presented a funding request for $22,000 annually, over the next 4 years. The DBA indicated that these funds would be used to leverage additional grant funding and sponsorships, and cited the following as opportunities for the coming year:
1. Botanical Improvements - Work together on planning and tree wells that reflect St. Albert’s botanical identity.
2. Downtown Murals - Explore locations, property-owner interest and partners for downtown murals.
3. More Public Seating - Identify location for benches and tree well seating that make visits more comfortable.
4. Simpler Event Planning - Develop a shared calendar, clear application steps and agreed approach to seasonal lighting.
Unpaid BIA Tax
The proportion of the tax levy collected by the City can vary from year to year. For example, a business may be assessed on the BIA tax roll but may have closed or relocated outside the BIA boundary, prior to issuance of the levy notice. Additionally, some businesses operating within the BIA remain non-compliant, and have been issued late penalties for non-payment, as a result.
The City is obligated to transfer the full BIA tax levy to the DBA, regardless of the amount collected. Consequently, any unpaid BIA taxes create a funding shortfall that is absorbed by the City. Since the establishment of the BIA, a total of $9,200 in BIA taxes remains outstanding, effectively resulting in additional financial support being provided to the DBA by the City.
Business Improvement Area Tax Levy & Tax Rate
The Business Improvement Area tax levy and tax rate are established through the Business Improvement Area Tax & Tax Rate Bylaw. Since establishment of the BIA, the amount payable by each business in the area has been set a minimum and maximum of $200.
As such, changes to either the amount each business pays or to the number of businesses within the BIA boundary affect the overall tax levy that can be collected and transferred to the DBA.
STAKEHOLDER COMMUNICATIONS OR ENGAGEMENT
It is unclear if the DBA’s broader membership, businesses within the BIA, received communication and engagement associated with the DBA’s funding request and the associated motion.
IMPACTS OF RECOMMENDATION(S)
Financial:
If approved, the City would provide the St. Albert DBA with an annual grant of $22,000 from 2027-2030, for a total of $88,000, funded from the Stabilization Reserve, which has sufficient funds.
As the DBA’s funding request did not provide financial details with respect to the opportunities they highlighted within their November 3, 2026, presentation, it is difficult to fully quantify and assess the additional indirect financial impacts of the proposed botanical improvements, downtown murals, additional public seating, and simpler event planning.
If the DBA can leverage this temporary supplemental funding to increase administrative and operational capacity within their organization and demonstrate more direct benefit back to their members, it may provide the organization with the opportunity to be more financially self-sufficient in the future, thus reducing the need for supplemental City funding.
Compliance & Legal:
The DBA is currently not compliant with the Downtown Business Improvement Area Bylaw requirement to provide the City with an audited financial statement, within 6 months of the end of the Association’s financial year.
This motion, and the provision of additional supplemental funding, may provide a funding alternative to compliance with the bylaw’s requirements.
Program or Service:
As the DBA’s funding request did not provide operational details associated with the opportunities they highlighted within their presentation, Administration’s ability to quantify and assess the program and service impacts is limited.
• Botanical Improvements - The City already has established service levels associated with the Annual Flower Program and standards associated with tree wells. Currently, the scope and impact of the DBA’s concept for botanical improvements are unclear.
• Downtown Murals - Murals on privately owned buildings would not fall under the City's Public Art program, as the Public Art Policy applies to municipally owned properties and facilities. This change was made to the most recent public art policy to reduce risk to the City. Responsibility for commissioning, artist selection, installation, maintenance, potential restoration, and removal would remain either with the property owner or DBA.
Administration could provide guidance on best practices related to artist selection, artist compensation, maintenance planning, and examples from comparable mural initiatives in other municipalities. Consideration should also be given to long-term stewardship, including how murals would be managed if property ownership changed and whether collaboration with relevant arts stakeholders could help support a cohesive downtown identity and avoid an ad-hoc approach to public-facing artwork.
• Public Seating - Within the BIA, there are twenty-four (24) public, City-owned and maintained, benches or seating. Bench seating within the BIA exceeds the municipal standard. There are also eight (8) privately-owned benches and seating in front of businesses and adjacent to the public sidewalk, which provides additional public seating.
Currently, the scope and impact of the DBA’s plan for additional public seating is unclear.
• Simpler Event Planning - The City provides support to several community-led events. Depending on the location and duration, such events may have additional regulatory, insurance, or legal requirements, such as road closures, liability insurance, licence agreements, emergency plans, and public notification requirements. The addition of more events may result in an increase in the level of service or operating cost required to accommodate and support more events.
More communication and detail from the DBA on the proposed shared calendar would be helpful in assessing the impact. As the City maintains a Community Events Calendar on our website, there may be an opportunity for the DBA to make better use of this existing resource, while also providing greater awareness of scheduled events and to help reduce conflicts with existing events and programming.
Organizational:
The DBA and the City’s strategics goals for downtown vibrancy are aligned. Multiple City departments currently provide in-kind support and assistance to the DBA, including Economic Development, Public Operations, Recreation & Parks, and Community Services. This support and assistance include sharing information and data, providing guidance on municipal processes and regulations, support for events, public tree lighting and storage, navigating infrastructure requests, and amending BIA bylaws, as well as performing the assessment, collection and transfer associated with the BIA tax levy.
As the DBA’s funding request did not provide details associated with the opportunities they highlighted within their presentation, Administration’s ability to quantify and assess the additional organizational impacts stemming from this funding is limited.
Risks
• Financial: To date, the City has not received a copy of the DBA’s 2025 audited statement. As a result, DBA has not received the final 50% of their approved budget, associated with the BIA tax levy.
As Council is responsible for approving the DBA’s annual budget, this bylaw requirement supports transparency and accountability for public funds, helps the City assess the DBA’s financial situation through an independent third party, provides the City with a financial risk management tool, and supports compliance with funding agreements. Providing additional funding, without previous financial requirements being met, presents some financial risk to the City.
Moreover, the motion, as written, does not stipulate any additional performance, service, financial, or reporting requirements associated with the grant funding.
• People: At present, there are no dedicated staff positions responsible for downtown vibrancy initiatives. Support for the DBA and related downtown projects is provided through a shared-resource model involving staff from multiple departments who contribute in addition to their primary responsibilities.
While this approach has allowed work to progress, the absence of dedicated capacity limits the organization's ability to provide consistent, sustained support and advance initiatives effectively. As much of the DBA’s work requires the support of and coordination with City staff, increasing support to the DBA without corresponding staffing resources risks further strain to existing capacity and may reduce the organization's ability to meet other operational and strategic objectives.
• Stakeholders:
DBA Members / Businesses within the Business Implements Area
As information has not been received from the DBA, Administration is not aware if most DBA members, through a formal vote, are in support of the funding request and proposed activities associated with this motion.
St. Albert Non-profit Event Organizers
The City, through the Community Event Grant Program, provides a source of funds for registered St. Albert non-profit societies to assist in defraying costs associated with organizing and running eligible community events. Through this program, organizers of funded events are required to provide a grant summary, final budget, and copies of receipts for expenses incurred directly related to the event.
There may be reputational risk to the City and equitability concerns, particularly amongst non-profit community event organizers who are required to apply and meet requirements through the Community Event Grant Program.
• Compliance and Legal: There are some compliance risks associated with the DBA’s adherence to the Downtown Business Improvement Area Bylaw. As noted previously, the DBA has not met an important bylaw requirement.
The DBA’s Annual General meeting was held on November 3, 2026. At the time of this report, Administration has not received information from the DBA regarding results of the Board Member nomination or its estimates of revenues and expenditures for the next year. As the DBA has not made public or provided a record of previous Board and AGM meetings, it is unclear if the DBA is adhering to Board Member and Member voting requirements.
ALIGNMENT TO PRIORITIES IN COUNCIL’S STRATEGIC PLAN
Initiative aligned with Strategic Plan:
Downtown Action Plan
ALIGNMENT TO LEVELS OF SERVICE DELIVERY
None at this time.
body
Report Date: November 24, 2026
Author(s): Mike Erickson (Director, Economic Development), Amanda MacDonald (Manager, Business Retention & Expansion)
Department: Economic Development
Department Director: Mike Erickson
Managing Director: Adryan Slaght (Dawny George, Acting MD)
Chief Administrative Officer: William Fletcher