TAMRMS#: B05
5.5
title
Transit Optimization Project (TOP) - TRAN-031
Notice given by: Councillor Clark
label
BUDGET POSTPONED MOTION:
recommendation
Subject to the Transit Optimization Project (TOP), TRAN-031 being approved by Council, that funding for Transit Growth Buses Chart No. TRAN-004, excluding the funding for two accessible transit/handibus type buses (City wide), be postponed until Council receives and reviews the TOP and provides further direction.
body
Administration’s Understanding of the Intent of the Motion:
Administration understands the intent of the motion is to defer funding associated with the two transit growth buses identified within Municipal Growth Capital Charter TRAN-004, while retaining funding for the two accessible transit/Handibus-type vehicles, until completion of the Transit Optimization Plan and subsequent Council review and direction.
SUMMARY
The proposed amendment would postpone acquisition of two growth transit buses pending completion of the Transit Optimization Plan. Administration's current assessment is that procurement of vehicles intended to support transit service expansion in developing neighbourhoods should proceed. Administration's preferred approach is reflected in a separate motion that would amend TRAN-004 by replacing the two conventional transit buses with two smaller transit vehicles better suited to Administration's current planning assumptions regarding future service delivery.
One developing neighbourhood is currently approaching, and may have already reached, the population thresholds identified within Council Policy C-TS-01 for transit service introduction. Additional growth areas are also actively developing and are expected to generate future transit demand.
Should Council approve TRAN-031 Transit Optimization Plan, Administration's current recommendation is to pursue the introduction of On-Demand Transit service within growth areas. The proposed smaller transit vehicles would support this service model immediately while also providing operational flexibility should future service requirements evolve. Deferring procurement may delay Administration's ability to introduce transit service to developing neighbourhoods and postpone the collection of ridership data necessary to inform future transit planning decisions.
ALIGNMENT TO COUNCIL DIRECTION OR MANDATORY STATUTORY PROVISION
N/A
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
The original TRAN-004 Transit Growth Buses charter included funding for two accessible transit/Handibus-type vehicles and two transit growth buses intended to support future transit service expansion. Administration has separately recommended that, subject to approval of TRAN-031 Transit Optimization Plan, the two conventional transit buses identified in TRAN-004 be replaced with two smaller transit vehicles. Administration's assessment of this motion is therefore focused on whether growth-area transit vehicles should be procured prior to completion of the Transit Optimization Plan, rather than on the specific vehicle type ultimately acquired.
Administration is concurrently seeking approval for TRAN-031 Transit Optimization Plan, which would evaluate opportunities to improve transit service delivery, network design, service effectiveness, service introduction methodologies, and long-term fleet requirements.
Administration's current recommendations are informed by internal transit subject matter expertise, operational experience, growth projections, and emerging transit industry practices. While Administration has sufficient internal transit expertise to identify preferred service delivery directions and establish planning assumptions, the Transit Optimization Plan is necessary to validate those assumptions, evaluate alternatives, quantify impacts, develop implementation strategies, establish performance measures, and provide Council with a comprehensive long-term transit service framework.
Council Policy C-TS-01 currently establishes the framework for introducing transit service to developing neighbourhoods. Based on Administration's current assessment, at least one growth area is approaching, and may already be meeting, the population thresholds identified within the policy for service introduction. Additional growth neighbourhoods continue to develop and are expected to generate increasing transit demand.
Administration's current planning assumptions contemplate the use of On-Demand Transit as an initial service model in developing neighbourhoods while ridership demand and travel patterns are established. These planning assumptions have informed Administration's recommendation to procure smaller transit vehicles, as they are capable of supporting both demand-responsive and conventional service requirements as transit demand evolves. This approach would allow transit service to be introduced earlier and more flexibly than traditional fixed-route implementation.
The proposed transit growth vehicles would support this approach by:
- Providing transit service to developing neighbourhoods sooner than would otherwise be possible.
- Supporting service across multiple growth areas rather than a single fixed route.
- Allowing ridership demand and travel patterns to be evaluated before larger investments are made.
- Providing flexibility to support future transit service requirements regardless of the ultimate recommendations arising from the Transit Optimization Plan.
Unlike conventional 40-foot transit buses, smaller transit vehicles have significantly shorter procurement timelines. Administration's preliminary market assessment indicates vehicle delivery could occur in as little as four months, compared to procurement timelines that may extend up to eighteen months for conventional transit buses. Given procurement timelines of approximately four months for smaller transit vehicles, Administration's recommendation is to acquire the vehicles now and utilize the Transit Optimization Plan to develop the detailed operating framework required to deploy them effectively.
Deferring the vehicle acquisition until completion of the Transit Optimization Plan would delay Administration's ability to implement service improvements and begin collecting operational data from developing neighbourhoods.
Administration believes the proposed vehicle acquisition remains appropriate regardless of the eventual findings of the Transit Optimization Plan, as the vehicles can support On-Demand Transit service, future growth area deployment, and other transit service requirements across the community, such as multiple use of the vehicle for conventional and paratransit services.
STAKEHOLDER COMMUNICATIONS OR ENGAGEMENT
No stakeholder engagement has been undertaken specifically regarding the proposed motion.
Administration's recommendation is informed by transit industry trends, operational experience, growth projections, fleet planning considerations, and preliminary planning assumptions associated with the Transit Optimization Plan.
Should Council approve funding for TRAN-031 Transit Optimization Plan, stakeholder engagement and public consultation activities would form part of that project.
IMPACTS OF RECOMMENDATION(S)
Financial:
If approved, this motion will reduce the required funding for TRAN-004 Transit Growth Buses by amount shared in Attachment- Confidential PM-27- 039 therefore increasing the amount of capital dollars available for future prioritized capital projects as well as emergent capital items.
If approved, there will also be a $200,000 reduction to the Transit Service Level Operating Funding business case which will subsequently be added to the omnibus.
Compliance & Legal:
None at this time
Program or Service:
The proposed motion would not affect acquisition of the two accessible transit/Handibus-type vehicles.
However, postponing acquisition of the two growth transit buses may delay Administration's ability to introduce transit service within developing neighbourhoods and may postpone implementation of future On-Demand Transit initiatives arising from the Transit Optimization Plan.
The proposed vehicles are intended to support the initial introduction of transit service and the evaluation of demand in growth areas. Delaying procurement would postpone the collection of ridership and service performance data that could help inform future transit planning decisions.
Organizational:
None at this time
Risks
While this would postpone near-term capital expenditure, there is a risk that deferring acquisition of the transit growth buses may delay Administration's ability to respond to service demands in developing neighbourhoods that are currently approaching or achieving service introduction thresholds.
Deferral may also delay implementation of On-Demand Transit initiatives that may arise from the Transit Optimization Plan by postponing availability of the fleet required to support those services.
Both the existing conventional fixed route model and the proposed On-Demand model require the procurement of additional buses, deferral of procurement may be subject to cost escalation, inflationary pressures, and updated vehicle pricing. Current realities of trade tariffs create uncertainty and may therefore reduce purchasing flexibility and increase future capital costs. In addition, delayed procurement may postpone the realization of service benefits associated with growth neighbourhood transit implementation.
Vehicle procurement timelines represent an additional risk. Smaller transit vehicles can typically be delivered substantially faster than conventional transit buses. Procuring the vehicles in advance of the completion of the Transit Optimization Plan would position the City to implement service improvements more quickly once Council direction is received.
Administration believes the risk of procuring growth-area transit vehicles prior to completion of the Transit Optimization Plan is low. Administration's preferred approach, outlined through a separate proposed amendment to TRAN-004, would utilize smaller transit vehicles capable of supporting multiple service delivery models and deployment scenarios. As a result, the proposed vehicles would remain valuable regardless of the ultimate recommendations arising from the Transit Optimization Plan.
ALIGNMENT TO PRIORITIES IN COUNCIL’S STRATEGIC PLAN
Initiative aligned with Strategic Plan:
None at this time
ALIGNMENT TO LEVELS OF SERVICE DELIVERY
E.1 Public Transit
E.1.1 Conventional Fixed Route Transit Services
body
Report Date: November 24, 2026
Author(s): Tim Saunders
Department: Public Operations
Department Director: Tim Saunders
Managing Director: Dinu Alex
Chief Administrative Officer: William Fletcher